浙江舟山定海一商户为防止快递丢失，先后两次在公共走廊安装360度旋转摄像头，拍摄范围覆盖隔壁店铺业主的进出必经通道，因侵害隐私权被法院判决拆除监控1。第一次安装时间为2023年10月，第二次为2025年1月1。
法院认定这一做法侵害了相邻业主的隐私权1。法官高嘉侃表示，"隐私侵权不以实际损害为前提，安装监控使他人出入信息处于随时可被记录的状态，即构成持续侵扰隐私"1。另一法官钱美生指出，该摄像头能够实时拍摄邻居的出行规律等隐私信息，"使他们丧失了对自身信息的选择暴露权和控制权，对隐私存在侵害和侵害的可能"1。经二审法院勘查和释法后，商户主动撤诉并拆除了摄像头1。
A merchant in Dinghai District, Zhoushan, Zhejiang province, faced two lawsuits after installing 360-degree rotating surveillance cameras in a shared hallway to prevent package theft.1 The cameras, installed first in October 2023 and again in January 2025, captured footage encompassing the entrance corridor that neighboring business owners must pass through to access their premises.1 The devices featured remote control and video playback capabilities.1
Courts ruled that the surveillance equipment violated the privacy rights of adjacent tenants.1 Judge Gao Jiakan established that privacy infringement does not require actual harm to occur; rather, installing monitoring that places others' movements at risk of constant recording constitutes ongoing privacy violation.1 Judge Qian Meisheng further determined that the camera could record real-time information about the movements and routines of the neighboring proprietors, denying them control over their personal information exposure.1 The primary court ordered the shopkeeper to remove the cameras.1 Following a site inspection and legal clarification by the appellate court, the defendant voluntarily withdrew the appeal and dismantled the surveillance equipment.1
评论
还没有评论，欢迎留下第一条。