发表于《皇家学会开放科学》的一项最新研究揭示,科学家群体内部对于“科学”的定义及其本质存在显著分歧,这种观点的不一致性实际上高于普通公众 1。该研究由Marina Dubova主导,她目前是加州大学伯克利分校的心理学助理教授,此前曾在圣塔菲研究所担任博士后研究员 1。合作研究者Qiawen E. Liu来自普林斯顿大学 1。研究团队调查了91名科学家和99名公众,让他们评估18种关于科学的描述,包括将科学比作侦探工作、追求真理的过程或现实的镜子等 1。这项研究获得了圣塔菲研究所Lou Schuyler Seed Grant Fund的资助 1。
尽管科学家与公众都认同好奇心在科学研究中的重要性,但双方在多个维度上表现出不同的认知倾向 1。科学家们在客观真理与创造性想象、既定程序与即兴适应之间意见不一,而公众则更倾向于将科学视为发现客观真理的可靠途径 1。值得注意的是,公众对科学的看法更接近于物理学家和生物学家的观点,而与心理学家和社会科学家的看法差异较大 1。这些认知差异不仅有助于解释公众为何常对科学界表现出的不确定性感到困惑,也引发了关于人工智能可能如何重塑未来科学发现过程的讨论 1。
A new study published in Royal Society Open Science reveals that scientists hold significantly divergent views on what constitutes "science," exhibiting even greater inconsistency than the general public 1. Led by Marina Dubova, a former postdoctoral researcher at the Santa Fe Institute and current assistant professor of psychology at UC Berkeley, the research investigated how different groups perceive the nature of scientific inquiry 1. The study assessed responses from 91 scientists and 99 members of the public regarding 18 distinct descriptions of science, such as viewing it as detective work, a pursuit of truth, or a mirror of reality 1.
While both scientists and laypeople agreed on the importance of curiosity, they differed sharply on key aspects of the scientific process 1. Scientists showed disagreement on issues such as objective truth versus creative imagination, and established procedures versus improvisation 1. In contrast, the public tended to view science more uniformly as a reliable method for discovering objective truth 1. Notably, public perceptions aligned more closely with those of physicists and biologists than with psychologists and social scientists 1. Co-author Qiawen E. Liu, affiliated with Princeton University, contributed to the analysis which highlights these epistemic divides 1.
These findings may help explain why the public often feels confused by scientific uncertainty, as their expectations of science differ from the internal debates among researchers 1. The study, supported by the Lou Schuyler Seed Grant Fund at the Santa Fe Institute, also sparked discussions on how artificial intelligence might reshape future scientific discovery given these varied definitions 1.
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。