受害者乔安妮·杨(Joanne Young)在温切斯特刑事法院出庭后,公开呼吁女性增强对刑事司法系统的信心 1。她放弃了匿名权,讲述了自己遭受多年药物控制及轮奸的经历 1。该案检察官、皇家检控署(CPS)专员詹姆斯·福斯特(James Foster)指出,办案过程中采用了“以嫌疑人为中心”的调查方法来构建案件 1。这一变化源于2019年针对强奸案调查失败的审查,旨在纠正过去过分审视受害者的做法 1。
2019年3月,特蕾莎·梅政府启动了对强奸案调查的审查,其于2021年发布的报告结论认为受害者被辜负 1。随后,在内政部的资助下,由贝齐·斯坦科(Betsy Stanko)和卡特琳·霍尔(Katrin Hohl)领导的“Soteria Bluestone行动”得以实施 1。尽管警方和检控方的起诉率已回升至2016年水平,但法院积压严重、审判等待时间长以及法官仍受“强奸迷思”影响等问题依然存在,表明司法系统的全面改革尚未完成 1。
数据显示,2016-17至2019-20年间,CPS提起的强奸案诉讼数量下降了60%,从5190起降至2102起 1。在此期间,保守党政府导致CPS工作人员减少30%,警察流失约2万人 1。截至2024年,警方报案数和CPS起诉数已恢复至2016年的水平 1。然而,目前约97%报告的强奸案从未进入法庭审理阶段,强奸幸存者平均需等待423天才能开庭受审 1。在拉塞尔·布兰德(Russell Brand)案中,其律师伊恩·温特(Ian Winter)仍使用“未抵抗或未尖叫”等陈旧辩护逻辑 1。
Joanne Young has waived her right to anonymity to publicly detail her ordeal of being drugged and gang-raped over several years, urging other women to regain trust in the criminal justice system 1. Speaking after appearing at Winchester Crown Court, Young highlighted a significant transformation in how UK authorities handle sexual violence and domestic abuse cases 1. James Foster, a prosecutor with the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS), noted that this case utilized a "suspect-centric" investigative approach, marking a distinct departure from historical practices that excessively scrutinized victims 1. This strategic shift stems from a 2019 review commissioned by Theresa May’s government into failing rape investigations, which concluded in a 2021 report that survivors had been let down 1. The review also led to the Home Office-funded "Soteria Bluestone" project, directed by Betsy Stanko and Katrin Hohl, aimed at correcting these systemic flaws 1.
Despite these procedural improvements, severe structural challenges remain within the courts. Between 2016-17 and 2019-20, the number of prosecutions brought by the CPS for rape dropped by 60%, falling from 5,190 to 2,102 cases 1. This decline coincided with a 30% reduction in CPS staff and the loss of approximately 20,000 police officers under Conservative government policies 1. Although police reporting numbers and CPS charging figures have since recovered to their 2016 levels as of 2024, only about 3% of reported rapes reach trial 1. Survivors of rape face an average wait of 423 days for their cases to be heard, while court backlogs continue to mount 1. Furthermore, outdated attitudes persist in legal proceedings; in the Russell Brand case, defense lawyer Ian Winter employed archaic arguments regarding whether the victim "resisted or screamed," demonstrating that judicial culture is still catching up with legislative and investigative reforms 1.
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。